Reviewing a sales call with the person who made it is one of the fastest ways to improve results. Done badly, it is also one of the fastest ways to make a good salesperson defensive. The difference is almost entirely in how the feedback is given.
Listen to the whole call first
Judging a call from the last five minutes is unfair and usually wrong. Problems at the close often start in the opening. Listen from the beginning and make notes with timestamps.
Ask before you tell
Start with their view: what went well, and what would they do differently? Most people identify their own weak moments accurately. When they name the issue themselves, they are far more likely to fix it.
Limit yourself to two points
You may notice ten things. Choose the two that would make the biggest difference and leave the rest for another day. Nobody can change ten habits at once.
Be specific
“You need to listen more” is no help. “At twelve minutes the prospect mentioned their budget was approved, and we moved straight on to features” is something a person can act on.
Name what worked
Not as a cushion before criticism, but because people repeat what gets noticed. Be just as specific about the good moments.
Practise the fix there and then
Ask them to say the improved version out loud. It feels awkward for thirty seconds and saves weeks. An idea that has been spoken once is much easier to use on the next real call.
Agree one thing to try
End with a single commitment for the coming week and check on it next time. Feedback without follow-up is forgotten by Friday.
Keep it regular and private
A short review every week is better than a long one every quarter, and it should always be one-to-one. Over a few months this habit does more for a team’s results than any training day.