Five Questions to Ask Before You Promote Your Best Salesperson to Manager

Your top salesperson has earned a promotion, and the obvious next step is to make them the sales manager. It is also one of the most common ways a company loses its best seller and gains a poor manager on the same day.

Selling and managing are different jobs. Before you decide, ask these five questions.

1. Do they want to manage, or do they want recognition?

Many high performers ask for a management title because it is the only form of progress on offer. Find out what they actually want. It may be more money, bigger accounts or a say in strategy, none of which requires a team to manage.

2. Do they already help other people succeed?

Look at how they behave now. Do colleagues go to them for advice? Do they share what works, or guard it? Someone who enjoys other people’s wins will probably enjoy managing. Someone who measures everything by their own figures may struggle.

3. Can they explain how they sell?

Some excellent salespeople work by instinct and cannot describe what they do. A manager has to teach. Ask them to walk a junior colleague through a deal and watch how clearly they explain it.

4. Can the business afford to lose their sales?

A new manager sells less, and often nothing at all. Work out how much revenue leaves with the promotion and who will replace it. If there is no answer, the timing is wrong.

5. Will they handle the difficult conversations?

Managing means telling a friend their performance is not good enough. Ask how they would approach that. An honest “I would find it hard” is a better sign than a confident answer that avoids the question.

Alternatives to a management role

  • A senior seller position with a higher earning ceiling.
  • A mentoring role for new starters, with time set aside for it.
  • Ownership of the largest accounts.

If you go ahead

Give them training before the title, not after. Agree a trial period, reduce their personal target and meet weekly for the first three months. The move can work very well, but only when it is a considered decision and not simply a reward.